The anniversary by tithi
The auspicious time of your wedding was chosen by the Hindu calendar: a tithi, a nakshatra, a lagna. Many couples keep the anniversary on the day that tithi returns in the same masa, visit the temple together and seek the blessings of their elders. Celebrating on the tithi is considered auspicious for the couple and the family.
The English date and the tithi drift apart by up to a few weeks, so the day changes every year. Sankh finds it for you.
Which time to enter
Enter the exact auspicious time (the mangalya dharana or jeelakarra-bellam moment) if you know it, because the tithi can change during the day. Weddings at night or in the early hours belong to the Hindu day that began at the previous sunrise; enter the actual date and time and the calculator takes care of this.
If you leave the time empty, the tithi at sunrise of the wedding date is used.
The rule followed
The anniversary is the day the wedding tithi prevails at sunrise in the same masa, at the city you choose. If the year has an Adhika masa with the wedding month's name, the anniversary is in the regular (nija) masa.